New York

Nursing homes in Erie County, New York

14
rated one or two stars
5
with an immediate jeopardy finding
28 of 33
staffed below the research benchmark for the residents they have
$827,384
in federal fines since 2023 across these 33 homes
17
towns with at least one nursing home

There are 33 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Erie County, across 17 towns. 14 of them are rated one or two stars, the lowest two grades Medicare gives. Medicare grades inspections on a curve inside each state, so those stars are a rank inside New York, not a national score.

All 33 nursing homes in Erie County

Every Medicare-certified nursing home with an address in Erie County, whichever town it is in. The labels on each card come from Medicare’s own records. What each one counts is below.

Filter and sort
Show only

Showing all 33 homes

Humboldt House Rehabilitation and Nursing Center 64 Hager Street, Buffalo 14208 · 173 beds Special Focus Facility candidateCarries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation3 immediate jeopardy findings on 2 inspections35% below expected staffing$270,666 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Highpointe on Michigan Health Care Facility 1031 Michigan Ave, Buffalo 14203 · 300 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation1 immediate jeopardy finding1 finding of actual harm$129,149 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Comprehensive Rehabilitation and Nursing Center at 147 Reist Street, Williamsville 14221 · 142 beds Resident property citation, no harm recorded1 immediate jeopardy finding36% below expected staffing$37,138 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Safire Rehabilitation of Northtowns, L L C 2799 Sheridan Drive, Tonawanda 14150 · 100 beds 1 immediate jeopardy finding30% below expected staffing
1 out of 5
Elderwood at Amherst 4459 Bailey Avenue, Amherst 14226 · 92 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded1 immediate jeopardy finding22% below expected staffing$25,262 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Buffalo Center For Rehabilitation And Nursing 1014 Delaware Ave, Buffalo 14209 · 200 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation3 findings of actual harm16% below expected staffing$139,721 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Fiddlers Green Manor Rehab and Nursing Center 168 West Main Street, Springville 14141 · 82 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation2 findings of actual harm42% below expected staffing$16,556 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Seneca Health Care Center 2987 Seneca Street, West Seneca 14224 · 160 beds 2 findings of actual harm25% below expected staffing$9,110 in federal fines
3 out of 5
Terrace View Long Term Care Facility 462 Grider Street, Buffalo 14215 · 390 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation2 findings of actual harm12% below expected staffing$30,843 in federal fines
3 out of 5
Elderwood at Cheektowaga 225 Bennett Road, Cheektowaga 14227 · 172 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded1 finding of actual harm34% below expected staffing
1 out of 5
Ellicott Center for Rehabilitation and Nursing 200 Seventh Street, Buffalo 14201 · 160 beds 1 finding of actual harm31% below expected staffing$10,868 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Williamsville Suburban, L L C 193 South Union Road, Williamsville 14221 · 220 beds Abuse or neglect citation1 finding of actual harm31% below expected staffing$43,973 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Elderwood at Williamsville 200 Bassett Road, Williamsville 14221 · 200 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded1 finding of actual harm30% below expected staffing$75,553 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Elderwood at Hamburg 5775 Maelou Drive, Hamburg 14075 · 166 beds 1 finding of actual harm40% below expected staffing$16,900 in federal fines
3 out of 5
Delaware Oaks Center for Rehabilitation and Nursin 1205 Delaware Avenue, Buffalo 14209 · 95 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded37% below expected staffing
2 out of 5
Safire Rehabilitation of Southtowns, L L C 300 Dorrance Avenue, Buffalo 14220 · 120 beds 31% below expected staffing
2 out of 5
Garden Gate Health Care Facility 2365 Union Road, Cheektowaga 14227 · 184 beds 27% below expected staffing
2 out of 5
Elderwood at Lancaster 1818 Como Park Blvd, Lancaster 14086 · 96 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded44% below expected staffing
3 out of 5
Elderwood at Grand Island 2850 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island 14072 · 90 beds 35% below expected staffing
3 out of 5
Absolut Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation at a 292 Main Street, East Aurora 14052 · 320 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded29% below expected staffing
3 out of 5
Brothers of Mercy Nursing & Rehabilitation Center 10570 Bergtold Road, Clarence 14031 · 240 beds 19% below expected staffing
3 out of 5
Canterbury Woods 725 Renaissance Drive, Williamsville 14221 · 50 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded
3 out of 5
Schofield Residence 3333 Elmwood Avenue, Kenmore 14217 · 120 beds 15% below expected staffing
4 out of 5
Greenfield Health & Rehab Center 5949 Broadway, Lancaster 14086 · 160 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded
4 out of 5
Harris Hill Nursing Facility, L L C 2699 Wehrle Drive, Williamsville 14221 · 192 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded33% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
Autumn View Health Care Facility L L C S 4650 Southwestern Blvd, Hamburg 14075 · 230 beds 32% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
Eden Rehabilitation Nursing Center 2806 George Street, Eden 14057 · 40 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded27% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
Father Baker Manor 6400 Powers Road, Orchard Park 14127 · 160 beds 19% below expected staffing$21,645 in federal fines
5 out of 5
Beechwood Health Care Center, INC. 2235 Millersport Highway, Getzville 14068 · 272 beds No standard inspection in over 2 years17% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
McAuley Residence 1503 Military Road, Kenmore 14217 · 160 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded15% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
St Catherine Laboure Health Care Center 2157 Main Street, Buffalo 14214 · 80 beds 10% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
Fox Run at Orchard Park One Fox Run Lane, Orchard Park 14127 · 60 beds No harm or jeopardy findings
5 out of 5
Mercy Hospital Skilled Nursing Facility 55 Melroy Avenue, Lackawanna 14218 · 84 beds No harm or jeopardy findings
5 out of 5

What the labels on each card mean

What a star means here

Medicare grades the inspection part of a star rating on a curve inside each state, so a star here is a rank against other New York homes, not a national score. Medicare withholds the rating altogether from homes on its Special Focus Facility list, so a withheld rating is a warning, not missing data.

Short on staffing

The home reports fewer nurse and aide hours per resident per day than a published research benchmark expects for the residents it actually has. The benchmark is not a Medicare figure: we work it out from the home's own Medicare case-mix score using the CASE formula (Harrington and others, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2025). It is not a legal limit, and there is no federal minimum number of nursing hours per resident per day.

Immediate jeopardy

The most serious result an inspection can have. It means inspectors found a resident was in danger of serious harm or death. A finding of actual harm is the level below that. Both are counts of inspection tags across the last three inspection cycles on record, not counts of separate incidents. Fines are federal penalties recorded between 2023 and 2026.

Abuse, counted two ways

There are two official measures and they do not agree. Medicare puts an abuse warning on a home's profile when abuse was found and a resident was harmed, or when it happened twice, and takes the warning off after a year. Separately, inspectors cite homes under the abuse, resident property and involuntary seclusion tags, and those findings stay on the record. A home can carry one label, both, or neither, so the two are labeled separately on every card.

The Special Focus list

Medicare's list of homes with a persistent record of serious problems. Each state gets a small number of places on it. A candidate is a home in line for one of those places.

Towns in Erie County

A town needs two homes to have its own page. The rest link straight to the home. Each count is the homes in Erie County, so a town that crosses the county line will show more on its own page.