Sarasota County

Nursing homes in Sarasota, Florida

10
rated one or two stars
7
with an immediate jeopardy finding
16 of 23
staffed below the research benchmark for the residents they have
$1.0 million
in federal fines since 2023 across these 23 homes

There are 23 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Sarasota. 10 of them are rated one or two stars, the lowest two grades Medicare gives. Medicare grades inspections on a curve inside each state, so those stars are a rank inside Florida, not a national score.

All 23 nursing homes in Sarasota

Every Medicare-certified nursing home with a Sarasota address. The labels on each card come from Medicare’s own records. What each one counts is below.

Filter and sort
Show only

Showing all 23 homes

Siesta Key Health and Rehabilitation Center 4602 Northgate Court, Sarasota 34234 · 120 beds Abuse or neglect citation7 immediate jeopardy findings1 finding of actual harm26% below expected staffing
3 out of 5
Aviata at Beneva 741 South Beneva Road, Sarasota 34232 · 120 beds Special Focus Facility candidateCarries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation4 immediate jeopardy findings2 findings of actual harm24% below expected staffing$110,129 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Indian Beach Nursing and Rehab Center 1755 18th St, Sarasota 34230 · 101 beds Carries Medicare’s abuse warningAbuse or neglect citation3 immediate jeopardy findings1 finding of actual harm27% below expected staffing$427,597 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Sarasota Health and Rehabilitation Center 1524 East Avenue South, Sarasota 34239 · 144 beds Abuse or neglect citation2 immediate jeopardy findings1 finding of actual harmNo standard inspection in over 2 years27% below expected staffing$230,102 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Crescent Health and Rehabilitation Center 5401 Sawyer Rd, Sarasota 34233 · 140 beds 2 immediate jeopardy findings30% below expected staffing$26,534 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Vivo Healthcare Meadows 5157 Park Club Drive, Sarasota 34235 · 120 beds 2 immediate jeopardy findings27% below expected staffing
1 out of 5
Springs at Lake Pointe Woods 3280 Lake Pointe Blvd, Sarasota 34231 · 101 beds Abuse or neglect citation1 immediate jeopardy finding2 findings of actual harm27% below expected staffing$51,671 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Aviata at Sarasota 1507 S Tuttle Ave, Sarasota 34239 · 120 beds Abuse or neglect citation3 findings of actual harm26% below expected staffing$39,846 in federal fines
1 out of 5
Pr SNF Operations LLC 5111 Palmer Ranch Parkway, Sarasota 34238 · 60 beds Abuse or neglect citation2 findings of actual harm20% below expected staffing$59,696 in federal fines
4 out of 5
Birchwood Health and Rehabilitation Center 3250 12th St, Sarasota 34237 · 87 beds 1 finding of actual harm30% below expected staffing
2 out of 5
Harborview Sarasota 4783 Fruitville Road, Sarasota 34232 · 81 beds Abuse or neglect citation1 finding of actual harm26% below expected staffing$43,839 in federal fines
2 out of 5
Sarasota Point Rehabilitation Center 2600 Courtland Street, Sarasota 34237 · 120 beds 1 finding of actual harm27% below expected staffing
4 out of 5
Hawthorne Center for Rehab & Healing of Sarasota 5381 Desoto Road, Sarasota 34235 · 120 beds 1 finding of actual harm27% below expected staffing$8,512 in federal fines
5 out of 5
Sarasota Memorial Nursing & Rehabilitation Center 5640 Rand Blvd, Sarasota 34238 · 120 beds 1 finding of actual harm
5 out of 5
Creekside Health and Rehabilitation Center 5511 Swift Road, Sarasota 34231 · 178 beds Involuntary seclusion citation, no harm recorded24% below expected staffing
2 out of 5
Bay Village of Sarasota 8400 Vamo Road, Sarasota 34231 · 95 beds No standard inspection in over 2 years
3 out of 5
Life Care Center of Sarasota 8104 Tuttle Ave, Sarasota 34243 · 120 beds 25% below expected staffing$18,780 in federal fines
4 out of 5
Plymouth Harbor Incorporated 700 John Ringling Blvd, Sarasota 34236 · 56 beds Abuse or neglect citation, no harm recorded
4 out of 5
Inn at Sarasota Bay Club 1303 North Tamiami Trail, Sarasota 34236 · 44 beds No harm or jeopardy findings
4 out of 5
Pines of Sarasota 1501 N Orange Ave, Sarasota 34236 · 171 beds No standard inspection in over 2 years12% below expected staffing
5 out of 5
Benderson Family Skilled Nursing and Rehab Center 1959 N Honore Ave, Sarasota 34235 · 45 beds No harm or jeopardy findings
5 out of 5
Sunnyside Nursing Home 5201 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota 34232 · 60 beds No harm or jeopardy findings
5 out of 5
Glenridge on Palmer Ranch INC. 7333 Scotland Way, Sarasota 34238 · 61 beds No standard inspection in over 2 years
5 out of 5

What the labels on each card mean

What a star means here

Medicare grades the inspection part of a star rating on a curve inside each state, so a star here is a rank against other Florida homes, not a national score. Medicare withholds the rating altogether from homes on its Special Focus Facility list, so a withheld rating is a warning, not missing data.

Short on staffing

The home reports fewer nurse and aide hours per resident per day than a published research benchmark expects for the residents it actually has. The benchmark is not a Medicare figure: we work it out from the home's own Medicare case-mix score using the CASE formula (Harrington and others, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2025). It is not a legal limit, and there is no federal minimum number of nursing hours per resident per day.

Immediate jeopardy

The most serious result an inspection can have. It means inspectors found a resident was in danger of serious harm or death. A finding of actual harm is the level below that. Both are counts of inspection tags across the last three inspection cycles on record, not counts of separate incidents. Fines are federal penalties recorded between 2023 and 2025.

Abuse, counted two ways

There are two official measures and they do not agree. Medicare puts an abuse warning on a home's profile when abuse was found and a resident was harmed, or when it happened twice, and takes the warning off after a year. Separately, inspectors cite homes under the abuse, resident property and involuntary seclusion tags, and those findings stay on the record. A home can carry one label, both, or neither, so the two are labeled separately on every card.

The Special Focus list

Medicare's list of homes with a persistent record of serious problems. Each state gets a small number of places on it. A candidate is a home in line for one of those places.

Sarasota County has 30 Medicare-certified nursing homes. The 8 outside Sarasota are in Venice (6), Englewood (1) and North Port (1).